Science fiction and fantasy                                            


by Gregory Maguire


If you enjoy books that are sprinkled with references to other literature then Lost has plenty to keep you going. It's the story of Winnie Rudge, an author who is stalled on her current project. She travels to England for research and inspiration, to her ancestral family home of Rudge House.

Winnie is writing about another writer, the character of Wendy Pritzke, who is researching the ghost of Jack the Ripper. So we have a writer writing about a writer writing about a writer, like mirrors reflecting each other into infinity. It's less repetitive than this might seem because of the way Gregory Maguire uses the device to drop hints about Winnie's inner thoughts.

When Winnie arrives in London she finds her cousin John missing, and the workmen who are supposed to be fixing the flat are too spooked to get anything done. Her downstairs neighbour is mad as a hatter, and no-one can tell her where John is. Her ancestor Ozias Rudge, who she believes was the inspiration for Dickens' A Christmas Carol, leers at her from an old portrait as the house is filled with unexplained noises. Rudge House is full of distractions for the blocked author, but as the plot thickens she realises she may have more pressing issues than the need to finish her book. But is she being haunted for real, or are the occurrences nothing more than the product of the fevered imagination of a lonely, neurotic and attention-hungry novelist?

The characters in this story are subtle, and they tend to display a biting humour which can be quite catty. Winnie experiences jealousy when it comes to Allegra, who has her own claims on John. She gets standoffishness from Ritzi Ostertag, a psychic who she considers to be a theatrical sham, and increasing distrust from the widow Rasia. Relationships like these result in some lively banter.

However I didn't get much sense of who Winnie is and what she stands for. She's neurotic and a bit wet, but other than those impressions she's hard to pin down. She's very much a cipher. To an extent her blandness is dictated by the plot, but even if it makes sense for her personality to be somewhat indistinct, this does nothing to make her an engaging protagonist.

Lost could refer to various people and objects, and as the narrative progresses so does our understanding of the title's meaning. It's sophisticated and cleverly plotted. Although events in the story are subdued rather than breathless or otherworldly there's a rich atmosphere, and certain presences, or indeed absences, seem to hang over Winnie like a guillotine. But unfortunately she doesn't have the passion of a truly inspiring heroine, which is why this novel didn't quite come alive for me.

31st August 2010

Book Details

Year: 2001

Categories: Books

    Female Protagonist  

If you like this, try:

Surrender cover    

Surrender by Rhiannon Paille
A tree tells a pair of young lovers that they must not see each other. The first in The Ferryman and the Flame series.

So Cold The River cover    

So Cold The River by Michael Koryta
A filmmaker takes on more than he bargained for when he agrees to document the life story of a dying billionaire.

Cracking Grace cover    

Cracking Grace by Steven Stromp
A girl bereaved of her mother and a statue in a cemetery find themselves asking the same questions.

3 star rating

Review © Ros Jackson