Science fiction and fantasy                                            

Hateful Heart

by Sam Stone


If there's one thing vampires have suffered in recent years, it's been a brutal de-fanging as they have moved from being portrayed as brutal killers to guilt-ridden lovers in popular fiction. The creatures in Sam Stone's Hateful Heart aren't immune to this softening trend, but they still have more than enough otherworldly iciness to make them worth reading about. This is the fourth book in the Vampire Gene series. However, although it features characters from the earlier books it stands quite well on its own as a mystery and it won't make new readers who aren't aware of all the back story feel lost.

The tale begins with a prologue concerning a mysterious veiled woman who hands out gifts to a couple of medieval knights. She tells them to look after these treasures and found an order. There's time travel and magic from the start, but I found this part hard to engage with because of the way the characters spoke. The knights were too polite, and they accepted what the woman said without much questioning, whilst the Lady sounded like someone out of Ladyhawke. Fortunately this corny lack of nuance only lasts for the five pages that make up the prologue, after which things sharpen up considerably.

A fair bit of the story is told in the first person from the point of view of Caesare, a.k.a. Chez, a vampire living in an uneasy threesome with Lilly and her other undead lover, Gabriele. They live underground beneath a castle like proper vampires, drinking human blood to keep themselves strong. Occasionally they kill people when they get too hungry and get carried away, but it's never out of sheer badness and they like to keep to themselves. Their quiet existence is disturbed when Amalia shows up. She's a weak new-born vampire, and she has bad news: one of their kind, an old friend of Lilly's, has been destroyed. The group decide that something with the power to kill an immortal is an immediate threat to them all, so they set off on the trail of it. They're looking for an artefact that targets the undead, but to do so they must confront its dangerous time-hopping wielder, Carduth.

The story jumps about from the present day to 2000 years in the past and various points in between, and it takes in a number of different points of view. This isn't as confusing as it sounds, although we're introduced to quite a lot of minor characters who are mainly there so they can die and show us how badly cursed this item they're chasing is.

Things get more interesting once the mystery develops and the relationships in the story are allowed to shift and grow. There's a striking contrast between the historical settings and the prosaic modern world of construction sites and offices. This novel improves considerably once it gets going, and it becomes a very readable and fast-paced tale with plenty of action and suspense. The character of Anja, an empath with the power to make people she touches remember whatever she wants them to, is intriguingly conflicted. She's no innocent, but as she tries to figure out who to trust readers are offered the same dilemma over whether or not to root for her.

Chez is often preoccupied by his feelings for Lilly, and I found his character a touch soppy. However it's easy to understand his jealousy of Gabi, and the conflict he feels between wanting his rival out of the way and not actually wishing his friend harm. But just when the vampires start to seem human they're apt to do something freakishly supernatural like flying, or to indulge in killings, so we're not allowed to forget their basic monstrosity.

Hateful Heart is a varied story that deals with a wide range of emotional states. There's sex, but it's just as likely to be creepy as it is tender or romantic, and anyway it's not the dominant theme. This is aimed squarely at adults, but it's not the kind of book that the "mature content" warning on the back might imply. The action is neither excessively grisly nor too tame, and the characters gain depth and become more believable as the story progresses. The time travel aspect is simply executed: people step through waterfall-like portals into other eras. The time-paradox problem is explained away as time being linear for the individual, so that a character can't go back and change anything that has already affected them. It doesn't stand up to scrutiny, but then time travel stories rarely do. It's a matter of suspending disbelief and enjoying the rest of the ride. Sam Stone doesn't mess about by baffling readers with science, instead she simply glosses over the issue.

Hateful Heart isn't a dumb book, but nor is it full of obscure cultural references or historical details that most people won't understand. So in most senses, this is a distinctly accessible, mainstream novel. There are vampires and that may imply a certain weirdness, but these are standard undead creatures similar to those in many other stories rather than a whole new sparkling incarnation of these fanged nightwalkers. The book needs proofreading, and the prologue could do with much subtler dialogue, but on the whole this is an exiting adventure and a solid mystery that I think will have wide appeal.

13th December 2011

Book Details

Year: 2011

Categories: Books


If you like this, try:

Solatium cover    

Solatium by Becca Mills
Beth Ryder has hidden powers that mark her out for a different life, but she is about to find out how different when she embarks on a fantastic and dangerous journey. The second novel in the Emanations series.

Carpathia cover    

Carpathia by Matt Forbeck
Passengers on the Titanic have more than shipwreck to deal with when come to prey on them.

Silver-Tongued Devil cover    

Silver-Tongued Devil by Jaye Wells
A series of murders threaten the fragile peace between vampires, mages, and the other dark races. The fourth in the Sabina Kane series.

4 star rating

Review © Ros Jackson


Steven     19th May, 2012 19:28pm

Do yourself a favor and do not buy this book. This book was SO BORING. I almost lost hope in humanity while reading this book.

Ros     24th May, 2012 12:30pm

Thanks for your comment, Steven. Not your cup of tea, then.