Science fiction and fantasy
A Discovery of Witches
by Deborah Harkness
Diana wants to deny her magic, but if she's caught up in a struggle that affects the future of all creatures she may not have the luxury of that choice. Can she suppress her growing feelings for Matthew, when their love is both forbidden and mutually dangerous?
The first thing that struck me about A Discovery of Witches is its similarities to Twilight. Matthew Clairmont is very much a vampire in the style of Edward Cullen: fiercely over-protective, preternaturally gorgeous, old-fashioned in his attitudes to women, passionate, and de-fanged. In terms of his knight in shining armour credentials he's far, far too perfect. He makes a few rumblings about his need to feed on blood and his scarcely-controllable hunting instincts, but without that frisson of danger he'd be nothing but a cuddly pin-up.
The vampires in this novel are all about wish fulfilment. They have very few of the traditional restrictions placed on vamps, they can walk in daylight, and they don't even have any fangs. They lead rich, interesting afterlives free from poverty and fear of disease, and they get to meet many of history's most colourful characters. A closer look at Matthew's life continues this aspirational theme: his is a world of hunting lodges, fine wines, antiques, French castles, helicopters, and well-stocked libraries. The book focuses on how very posh the vampires are, with a surfeit of cosy mealtime scenes and tours of Clairmont's well-stocked cellars. I found this domestic aspect slow-paced and somewhat dull.
Luckily the pace improves as soon as various other characters intrude on Diana and Matthew's home lives, and we get to the drama that the first half of the novel was largely missing. The story doesn't do badly for action when you consider how much of it is centred around old books and lost pages of manuscripts. In some ways it's erudite, but not overwhelmingly so and never to the extent of being dry as a bone.
However, for all that this is a book about hunger for knowledge and blood and forbidden passions, it didn't succeed in sharpening my curiosity as much as I had hoped it would. This was partly because magic is used less as a metaphor for something else and more as a way of making the heroine look special. When its purpose is merely to get her out of trouble at the last minute it seems something of a cop out. Although this is a danger with all magical fantasy it's worse in this novel because there's so much wish fulfilment going on overall.
My other main objection was Matthew Clairmont, a character I found stiflingly chivalrous. He's a romantic ideal of a man, unfailingly gentle towards those he loves whilst struggling to keep his dark urges in check. He'd be more believable if he had rougher edges, and more likeable if he was more flawed. Diana Bishop at least makes an effort not to play the damsel in distress all the time, but when faced with an alpha male like Matthew it's only ever going to be a token effort.
This story has its good points: the scholarly twist, the pace towards the end, and the novel world of magic and creatures. But the attitudes of its protagonists are stuck in the past, and it needs stronger, more independent female characters.
10th January 2011
If you like this, try:Twilight by Stephenie Meyer
When Bella moves to the small town of Forks she notices Edward Cullen is not like other young men.
Interview With The Vampire by Anne Rice
In the first episode of The Vampire Chronicles a reluctant vampire recounts his life story to date.
Belladonna by Anne Bishop
The second novel in the Ephemera series focuses on the rogue landscaper Belladonna.
Add your thoughtsAll comments are pre-moderated. Please do not post spoilers or abusive language.